As for the dangers of contraceptives, teenagers
Read the text below and answer the following
question based on it.
Women taking pill more likely to be
treated for depression, study findsMillions of women worldwide use hormonal contraceptives,
and there have long been reports that they can affect mood.
A research project was launched in Denmark to look at the
scale of the problem, involving the medical records of more
than a million women and adolescent girls.
It found that those on the combined pill were 23% more
likely to be prescribed an antidepressant by their doctor,
most commonly in the first six months after starting on the
pill. Women on the progestin-only pills, a synthetic form of
the hormone progesterone, were 34% more likely to take
antidepressants or get a first diagnosis of depression than
those not on hormonal contraception.
The study found that not only women taking pills but also
those with implants, patches and intrauterine devices were
affected.
Adolescent girls appeared to be at highest risk. Those
taking combined pills were 80% more likely and those on
progestin-only pills more than twice as likely to be
prescribed an antidepressant than their peers who were not
on the pill.
The researchers, Øjvind Lidegaard of the University of
Copenhagen and colleagues, point out that women are
twice as likely to suffer from depression in their lifetime as
men, though rates are equal before puberty. The fluctuating
levels of the two female sex hormones, oestrogen and
progesterone, have been implicated. Studies have
suggested raised progesterone levels in particular may
lower mood.
The impact of low-dose hormonal contraception on mood
and possibly depression has not been fully studied, the
authors say. They used registry data in Denmark on more
than a million women and adolescent girls aged between 15
and 34. They were followed up from 2000 until 2013 with an
average follow-up of 6.4 years.
The authors call for more studies to investigate this possible
side-effect of the pill.
Adaptado de: <
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/sep/28/women-takingcontraceptive-pill-more-likely-to-be-treated-for-depression-studyfinds> Acessado em 29 de setembro de 2016.
Gabarito comentado
Alternativa correta: D
Tema central: leitura crítica de texto informativo — identificar quem é o grupo mais afetado por um fenômeno descrito (no caso, efeitos do contraceptivo sobre o humor).
Resumo teórico rápido: em questões de interpretação procure a frase que expressa comparação ou grau (palavras como highest risk, porcentagens, “more likely”, “twice as likely”). Essas informações geralmente oferecem a resposta direta sobre quem sofre mais ou menos impacto.
Justificativa da alternativa D: o texto afirma que “Adolescent girls appeared to be at highest risk” e apresenta números claros: adolescentes em pílula combinada eram 80% mais propensas e em pílula só com progestina “more than twice as likely” a receber antidepressivo — isso confirma que D (proved to be the ones most likely to endure its wicked effects) reflete corretamente a ideia central do trecho.
Análise das alternativas incorretas:
A — “have experienced the least problems”: contradiz o texto que diz que adolescentes são os mais em risco.
B — “outnumber both older women and young adults”: o texto não trata de número absoluto de usuárias, trata de risco; opção irrelevante e não suportada.
C — “are free from them as long as they’re on progestin-only pills”: falso — o estudo indica aumento de risco com progestin-only (mais de 2x em adolescentes).
E — “have not been inflicted their devastating effects in any way”: contraditório; o texto relata efeito e porcentagens, logo não é verdadeiro.
Estratégias rápidas para o concurso: 1) busque comparativos e superlativos; 2) cheque números/percentuais que confirmam afirmações; 3) desconfie de alternativas que introduzem fatos não mencionados (como “outnumber”); 4) leia o enunciado mentalmente substituindo “adolescent girls” por “grupo X” para ver coerência.
Fonte: reportagem adaptada a partir de The Guardian (estudo dinamarquês) — use esse tipo de referência para confirmar dados em provas.
Gostou do comentário? Deixe sua avaliação aqui embaixo!






