Questão 1ab5550e-af
Prova:UECE 2013
Disciplina:Inglês
Assunto:Interpretação de texto | Reading comprehension

As to the effectiveness of managers, researchers have found, after many years of study, that

TEXT


      Hundreds of studies have assessed leadership styles, mainly by having employees report on how their managers typically behave. Researchers have also collected information on how effective managers are. After large numbers of such studies became available, reviewers aggregated them quantitatively to discover what kinds of leadership are effective.

      One conclusion that has emerged based on the research of the past 30 years is that a hybrid style known as transformational leadership is highly effective in most contemporary organizational contexts.

      A transformational leader acts as an inspirational role model, motivates others to go beyond the confines of their job descriptions, encourages creativity and innovation, fosters good human relationships, and develops the skills of followers. This type of leadership is effective because it fosters strong interpersonal bonds based on a leader’s charisma and consideration of others. These bonds enable leaders to promote high-quality performance by encouraging workers rather than threatening them, thus motivating them to exceed basic expectations.

      By bringing out the best in others, transformational leaders enhance the performance of groups and organizations.

      Transformational leadership is androgynous because it incorporates culturally masculine and feminine behaviors. This androgynous mixing of the masculine and feminine means that skill in this contemporary way of leading does not necessarily come naturally. It may require some effort and thought.

      Men often have to work on their social skills and women on being assertive enough to inspire others. It is nonetheless clear that both women and men can adapt to the demands of leadership in the transformational mode.

      One of the surprises of research on transformational leadership is that female managers are somewhat more transformational than male managers. In particular, they exceed men in their attention to human relationships. Also, in delivering incentives, women lean toward a more positive, reward-based approach and men toward a more negative and less effective, threat-based approach. In these respects, women appear to be better leaders than men, despite the double standard that can close women out of these roles.

      Why are women leaders more transformational when they are less likely to become leaders in the first place? One reason is that the double standard that slows women’s rise would work against mediocre women while allowing mediocre men to rise. As a consequence, the women who attain leadership roles really are better than the men on average.

      It is also true women generally avoid more domineering, “command and control” behavior because of the backlash they receive if they lead in this way. Men can often get away with autocratic behavior that is roundly disliked in women. Ironically, this backlash against domineering women may foster good leadership because the androgynous middle ground is more likely to bring success. Leaders gain less from ordering others about than from forming teams of smart, motivated collaborators who together figure out how to solve problems and get work done.

From: http://www.nytimes.com/ 2013/03/20  

A
an inspirational style can encourage creativity among mediocre men.
B
masculine behavior leans toward a reward-based approach.
C
the androgynous pattern seems to be preferred by men.
D
the so-called transformational style is very positive in many contexts.

Gabarito comentado

J
João Costa Monitor com apoio de IA

Gabarito: D

Fundamento decisivo: O critério decisivo é a correspondência semântica com a conclusão explícita da pesquisa. O enunciado pede o que os pesquisadores concluíram “after many years of study”, e o texto afirma que “transformational leadership is highly effective in most contemporary organizational contexts”; por isso, a alternativa D é a correta ao reformular essa ideia.

Tema central: eficácia da liderança transformacional
Análise das alternativas
A
Errada
Incorreta por extrapolação indevida e combinação artificial de ideias separadas. O texto diz que o líder transformacional inspira e encoraja criatividade, mas não afirma que esse estilo incentive criatividade entre “mediocre men”. A expressão “mediocre men” aparece em outro contexto, ligada ao duplo padrão que permite a ascensão de homens medianos com mais facilidade que mulheres medianas. Não é a conclusão geral sobre eficácia pedida na questão.
B
Errada
Incorreta por inversão factual. O texto afirma expressamente que “women lean toward a more positive, reward-based approach and men toward a more negative and less effective, threat-based approach”. Portanto, a abordagem reward-based não é associada ao comportamento masculino, mas ao feminino.
C
Errada
Incorreta por ausência de suporte textual. O texto afirma que a liderança transformacional é andrógina porque combina comportamentos culturalmente masculinos e femininos, e que tanto homens quanto mulheres podem se adaptar a esse modo de liderança. Em nenhum momento se afirma que esse padrão seja preferido pelos homens.
D
Certa
A alternativa D está correta porque reexprime a conclusão central apresentada no texto: “One conclusion that has emerged based on the research of the past 30 years is that a hybrid style known as transformational leadership is highly effective in most contemporary organizational contexts.” O núcleo decisivo é “highly effective in most contemporary organizational contexts”, preservado semanticamente em “very positive in many contexts”. A questão pede justamente essa conclusão geral das pesquisas sobre eficácia gerencial.
Pegadinha da questão
A banca mistura alternativas com palavras do texto, mas desloca a relação lógica: a pergunta pede a conclusão geral das pesquisas sobre eficácia, e não detalhes sobre diferenças entre homens e mulheres ou sobre “mediocre men”.
Dica para questões semelhantes
  • Quando o enunciado pedir o que a pesquisa concluiu, localize no texto a frase que resume explicitamente a conclusão, não detalhes secundários.
  • Aceite paráfrase quando o núcleo do sentido for preservado, como “highly effective” equivalente a “very positive”.
  • Elimine alternativas que reutilizam vocabulário do texto, mas unem informações de parágrafos diferentes sem que o autor tenha feito essa ligação.
  • Verifique se a alternativa mantém a atribuição correta dos fatos; inversões como reward-based para homens, quando o texto atribui isso às mulheres, invalidam a opção.

Estatísticas

Aulas sobre o assunto

Questões para exercitar

Artigos relacionados

Dicas de estudo